Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Blog Article

By Guest Commentator Amy Kedron
Posted on June 27, 2008

To be sure, many urban neighborhoods are in dire need of development resources. But there is a difference between "economic development" and "community economic development." The former is often driven by private interests, primarily for private gain; the latter is community-driven and aims to empower communities.

The Local Initiatives Support Corporation (LISC) has long tried to walk the fine line between private interest and public benefit, as it has helped provide billions of dollars to low income communities. But at a recent Urban Forum I attended in April, LISC's invited speakers – and LISC itself – appeared to be veering far from community development.

LISC is an economic development intermediary whose stated purpose is "to transform distressed neighborhoods into healthy and sustainable communities of choice and opportunity, good places to work, do business and raise children." It mobilizes the philanthropic dollars of some of the largest corporations in America to develop affordable housing, retail districts, charter schools and even football fields. Its corporate sponsors, such as State Farm Insurance, the Walton Family Foundation, the National Football League, and Citigroup, have donated over $7.8 billion over the past 25 years.

When LISC began almost thirty years ago, its primary emphasis was on affordable housing; today its sights are set on retail, of the big box variety, as the Forum’s keynote speakers Colvin Grannum and Harvey Gutman discussed at great length.

Colvin Grannum is the president of Brooklyn's Bedford Stuyvesant Restoration Corporation (BSRC), the first community development corporation in the nation. (He has also served on the board of LISC since 2001.) According to the 2000 Census nearly one-third of Bed-Stuy families in the largely African-American community lived in poverty.

Grannum began his presentation emphasizing the importance of local business ownership. This is, of course, a key principle of organizations like the Business Alliance for Local Living Economies (BALLE). But Grannum's speech left out a pivotal word that BALLE emphasizes – independence.

Local economies advocates understand how a franchise and an independently-owned business can have vastly different economic and community impacts. Economic multiplier studies repeatedly demonstrate that independent retailers return over three times more money to their communities than national retailers. Unlike large corporations, privately-held, independent businesses are not beholden to shareholders and therefore have a greater capacity to hear and respond to the needs of their communities; they also enhance an area's sense of place. For example, in a recent New York Times blog article entitled, "What Do You Miss Most about Old New York?," online readers repeatedly reminisced about their favorite "mom and pop" business.

Grannum's focus was different. He argued that franchise-models were the ideal formulas for urban renaissance. To drive this home Grannum highlighted the BSRC's main LISC-sponsored success stories, the new presence of a Duane Reade pharmacy and an Applebee's Bar and Grill in the neighborhood. Duane Reade began in 1960 and now with nearly 250 outlets is the largest drug store chain in New York City. It went public in 1998 and recorded $1.6 billion in sales in 2006. In 2007, Applebee's International Incorporated was sold to IHOP Corporation for $2.1 billion. IHOP Corporation now has more than 3,250 restaurants and is the largest full-service restaurant company in the world.

Conference leaders often referred to bringing in large retailers like these as economic "anchors" of otherwise independent districts. But these are anchors that can sink the ship. Writers such as Stacy Mitchell have detailed how big businesses often get big by cannibalizing smaller ones that are unable to attract the subsidies and support that give mega-retailers the competitive edge. LISC endorsement of large over small-scale development can be seen as undermining the competitiveness of homegrown neighborhood businesses. Major funding intermediaries like LISC should be asked to quantify the community impact of large-scale retail before they can deem such development a success.

The Urban Forum's second speaker, Harvey Gutman, similarly championed large-scale business development in New York neighborhood that had traditionally hosted smaller-scale shops. Gutman is the former Senior Vice President of Retail Development for Pathmark, the twelfth-largest supermarket chain nation-wide.

Gutman is best known for bringing a Pathmark supermarket to Harlem in 1999. It was the first chain supermarket to open in Harlem in three decades and the first major commercial development completed in the neighborhood since the riots of the 1960s. When the $15 million outlet opened on Harlem's 125th Street, local journalists questioned whether independents already rooted in the community would be able to compete. Pathmark was about eight times the size of the average supermarket there. Ethnically-owned, independent markets in East Harlem launched a major campaign against the store, questioning why the city would subsidize a nonlocal chain over local stores that had served the community throughout the previous decades.

Someone needed to remind Gutman that independent retail brings a key element to urban centers that has been deficient for decades – ownership. When a chain store opens it may create minimum-wage jobs, but when an independent store opens it creates community owned and controlled assets that have the potential to stabilize neighborhoods as they are inherited from one generation to the next. Culturally rich cities like Harlem and Bed-Stuy are resource-poor today at least partly because community development institutions routinely fail to nurture community ownership.

It's hard not to have some sympathy for urban communities that want to have the same retail opportunities as the suburbs. Harlem had gone without a chain supermarket for so long that when Pathmark opened Governor Pataki held a press conference there. Yet these long-neglected communities should beware corporate giants bearing gifts.

While these two keynotes may not capture the full scope of LISC priorities, they highlight the best thinking LISC had to offer for the coming year. What these perspectives lack is the recognition that community and entrepreneurial empowerment can and should be at the heart of local economic development efforts. Instead, LISC has championed an approach that focuses on retail recruitment of nonlocal "anchors" rather than strengthening those locally-owned businesses truly anchored to the culture, economy and long-term well-being of their communities.

Ultimately, really beneficial development requires diverse, independent businesses that build up entrepreneurship, capital, and purchasing power in a community. Urban leaders, including those at LISC, need to reexamine their development priorities and who exactly will benefit.

Amy Kedron is the founding director of Buffalo First, a BALLE network based in Buffalo, NY. She is writing a book on local economies and urban community development.

Re: Memo to Obama Transition Team: Home-Run Policies for ...

Submitted by Jets Shop (not verified) on September 2, 2010 - 9:22pm.

Jets Jerseys
Mark Sanchez Jersey
LaDainian Tomlinson Jersey
Antonio Cromartie Jersey
Brett Favre Jersey
Darrelle Revis Jersey
Dustin Keller Jersey
Jerricho Cotchery Jersey
Joe Namath Jersey
Jonathan Vilma Jersey
Laveranues Coles Jersey
Leon Washington Jersey
Santonio Holmes Jersey
Shonn Greene Jersey
Thomas Jones Jersey
Vernon Gholston Jersey
Jets Men's Jerseys
Jets Authentic Jerseys
Jets Premier Jerseys
Jets Replica Jerseys
Jets Women's Jerseys
Jets Kids Jerseys
Jets Hats
Cowboys shop
Cowboys Jersey
Miles Austin Jersey
Tony Romo Jerseys
Dez Bryant Jersey
Saints Jerseys
Reggie Bush Jerseys
Drew Brees Jerseys
Garrett Hartley Jerseys
Scott Fujita Jerseys

Re: Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 2, 2010 - 5:38am.

While most of the other couples are already prepping for the upcoming season of "Dancing With the Stars," there are two MBT
dancers who have yet to even meet.

Karina Smirnoff and "JerseyMBT Shoes
Shore" star Mike "The Situation" Sorrentino haven't even spoken to each other yet, but Smirnoff is sure they will have a lot to catch up on when he does eventuallyMbt Cleanrance make it to rehearsalsMBT Walking Shoes sometime later this month.

"I'm excited and nervous MBT Shoes Shop
and I have all these weird emotions, MBT Barabara but I'm mostly excited," Smirnoff told MTV News on MBT Changa Wednesday (September 1). "I MBT Chapa
think were literallyMBT Chili the only couple who will only have aboutMBT Fanaka
five days to get ready for the premiere on nationalMBT Karani television. Everyone else is going to have three and half weeks. MBT Kaya
We're gonna have maybe five days, so that part I'm very nervousMBT Lami about. I know I have to be very MBT M Walk clever in the choreography, because five days is just notMBT Sandals enough. Even if you're a professional dancer, it would be really, really tough toMBT Shuguli get ready. So we might try to implement the fist-pumping for the first episode."

Smirnoff joked that MBT Sport she thinks that the Situation's only dancing experience is in SeasideMBT Tariki Heights nightclubs, so she knows it's going to take some creative solutions on her end to MBT Tataga make him look like a professional dancer. "Once I meet him for the first time, whenever he's here, MBT Tembea that would be literally the first time I see him [and] I speak to him [and] I have any kind MBT Tunisha of contact with him, so leading up to that, I will try to create, like, variations, MBT Voi
little pieces of choreography," she explained. "It's trial and error."

And if fans think MBT Shoes Sorrentino will just be showing up shirtless week after week, Smirnoff is hoping they can show MBT Walking Shoes a new side of the TV star. "I was thinking, again, it's all about seeing where his mind is. Cheap MBT Shoes If that was up to me, we all know Mike as Mike 'The Situation' from 'Jersey Shore,' so MBT Sneakers I think it'd be nice to still have Mike as Mike that we know, but also show some more insightMBT Barabara Shoes into him wearing a tuxedo, wearing something we've never seen. MBT Changa Shoes I hope we're able to give different sides of Mike.

"He looks like he's in great physical shape, MBT Chapa Shoes and that's a plus and a minus," MBT Chili Shoes she said. "I don't know if Michael is ready, but he's going to be stretched out to hisMBT Fanaka Gtx Shoes limits, physically speaking."
MBT Karani Shoes
MBT Kaya Shoes
MBT Lami Shoes
MBT M.Walk Shoes
MBT Sandals
MBT Shuguli Gtx Shoes
MBT Sport Shoes
MBT Tariki Shoes
MBT Tataga Shoes
MBT Tembea Shoes
MBT Tunisha Shoes
MBT Voi Shoes

nike dunk

Submitted by nike dunk (not verified) on September 1, 2010 - 9:59pm.

linda
I love the nike dunk that I purchased. They are stylish and unbeliebably comfortable. Wearing them, it feels like I'm walking on pillows. Perfect support. Here comes a new pair of Air Jordan Shoes that are sure to be at the top of plenty of young ladies'back to school shopping lists. These little Michael Jordan Shoes are cute as can be with glittery blue sections contrasting an otherwise white design. But as is the case with the iridescent finish on the blue parts, the best features of these kicks require a closer look. That's where you'll find some previously hidden tonal flower designs that add just the right amount of summery shine to these playful dunks shoes.Im a big dude and at first i was unsure how they would fit becaue they look thin in the middle of the Coach Bags but when i put them on and walked for the first time with these Coach Outlet, i was like wow, this is the most comfortable shoe ive ever worn.

Re: Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 1, 2010 - 6:44am.

dell laptop batteries,laptop batteries, laptop charger, hp battery, dell inspiron 6000 battery dell inspiron 6000 hp adapter acer ac adapter vgp ac19v19 hp laptop battery hp ac adapter hp laptop batteries pa3399u 2brs skype phone dell laptop battery laptop battery gateway laptop battery sony vaio laptop battery dell ac adapter hp ac adapter toshiba laptop battery, leather handbags fashion handbags aluminum briefcase, aluminum cosmetic case aluminum tool case, aluminum train case. hp laptop battery ibm thinkpad battery acer laptop battery huolishaoseo

Re: Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Submitted by xihayizu (not verified) on August 29, 2010 - 5:44am.

Swarovski crystals of heart shape platinum plating color chain falls is swarovski work true attention. The Chestnut cutting pink quartz swarovski crystals has highlighted you romantic enchanting. Exquisite careful passes the plain text to inlay the swarovski beads quartz; it has an unconventional idea the jewelry for this set to pour swarovski jewelry into the extraordinary charm. This model of chain falls plays the swarovski bracelet part on the chain in the platinum plating color catena type.

Re: Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Submitted by xihayizu (not verified) on August 29, 2010 - 5:42am.

At this point, Swarovski wholesale is succinct besides swarovski the low key, the black small foreign-style clothing and it is also swarovski crystals representing the mystical feeling, increases the enticement swarovski jewelry charm for the world's the female. Each dazzling masterpiece which is designs specially, will swarovski wholesale include in the manufacture, the style magnificent photography centralism, it will take this project international project the luxurious record.

Re: Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Submitted by aa (not verified) on August 28, 2010 - 8:51am.

Our team of professionals shares a huge passion for high quality replica gucci, excellently crafted louis vuitton Replica Purses and stylish chanel Replica Sunglasses.

Re: Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Submitted by xihayizu (not verified) on August 28, 2010 - 5:30am.

By Eric’s design and the wristwatch which promotes in last year swarovski world clock and watch jewelry exhibition in the red spot design big prize, it reaches swarovski crystals the best product design in 2010. This swarovski jewelry is an unprecedented perfect work. Swarovski sale enters the clock and watch market bravely swarovski bracelet for the first time in 2009 through the world clock and watch jewelry swarovski rings exhibition, the brand breaks the outmoded rules and regulations.

Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes

Submitted by Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes (not verified) on August 27, 2010 - 7:44am.

We have Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes | Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes with top quality for women show women's taste.A pair of Christian Louboutin Boots | Christian Louboutin Boots in your closet will help you to transform any outfit.Christian Louboutin thigh high boots | Christian Louboutin thigh high boots are going mainstream.Choose the height of the heels to suit your personal preference. And Christian Louboutin Tall Boots | Christian Louboutin Tall Boots are coupled with sound support to showcase their beautiful legs.Christian Louboutin not only provide a variety of pumps, sandals, but also Christian Louboutin Ankle Boots | Christian Louboutin Ankle Boots.With Christian Louboutin sandals | Christian Louboutin sandals,you'll be charming, sexy, and so sophisticated.It seems that people who always love to choose Christian Louboutin short boots | Christian Louboutin short boots.Never be surprised if someone tells you she got a pair of Christian Louboutin Pumps | Christian Louboutin Pumps proudly.However many forget that they have some interesting Christian louboutin men's shoes | Christian louboutin men's shoes designs up their sleeves.

Re: Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Submitted by jewellery (not verified) on August 25, 2010 - 8:29am.

The best jewel piece for a girl links of london with a heart-shape face is the one that is wider at the bottom because once again that will balance out that chin. Women will never be content with the jewelry in the casket, and they are always dreaming of a more brilliant one. Because links of london jewellery of the reason that few people could withstand shining links of london jewels which are often engraved: links of london that is peculiar to links of london Company. Since jewels, as an indispensable ornament to dresses, links of london bracelet play an important role in displaying one’s distinctive personalities if they are properly matched. But it is hard for people to master the links of london rings tips in choosing jewelries properly.

Re: Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Submitted by jewellery (not verified) on August 25, 2010 - 8:26am.

Opposite to the round face, links of london bracelet a rectangle wants to add width to take away from you length, so you want to stick with shorter and thicker links of london jewellery necklaces having lots of chokers. Besides, a good drop earring compliments a square face, while a button style looks best on a links of london bracelet rectangular face. The traditional bun matched with drop earrings will give others an impression of elegance. The extremely fashionable links of london rings s should be avoided. Jewelries in simple design are better for dresses with many bordering ornaments.

Classic Cardy Ugg Boots

Submitted by Classic Cardy Ugg Boots (not verified) on August 25, 2010 - 3:51am.

So many people love Classic Cardy Ugg Boots | Classic Cardy Ugg Boots now.If you want to sent your friend a birthday present,I advice you give him or her a pair of Ultra Short UGG Boots | Ultra Short UGG Boots os his/her birthday gift!For modern women, who love beauty most, Classic Mini UGG Boots | Classic Mini UGG Boots show them an irresistible charming,The feature of Classic Metallic UGG Boots | Classic Metallic UGG Boots is that it can keep your feet dry and suit for you to wear in all seasons.What's more the Highkoo UGG Boots | Highkoo UGG Boots is a fun, modern update to one of our heritage styles, Fluff Flip Flop UGG Slippers | Fluff Flip Flop UGG Slippers is one of new 2010 fall series. Classic UGG Boots | Classic UGG Boots are perfect for you when you are around home or even when you are going out.

Re: Slipped LISC: Is Any Development Good for Urban America?

Submitted by jewellery (not verified) on August 23, 2010 - 8:19am.

Taking her age, taste, links of londonstatus, and figure into consideration, global women in the middle class get an ideal example to follow. links of london jewellery As for these professional women with high positions, they also finally get a jewelry model who friendship bracelets deserves to be imitated.It is well acknowledged that Michelle Obama has a special affection toward pearls. Besides, she tries to stack up her jewels by wearing Cartier Links London Watch upon Tiffany, winning a wide admiration.