Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Blog Article

Posted on May 28, 2008

I was tempted to fire off a letter to the editors at Fast Company, suggesting a better fact checker before they publish commentaries like Elizabeth Spiers' "Not So Fast: Neighborhoodlums" (June 2008, p. 128), the latest mass-media sneer at local-first campaigns. But it finally dawned on me that the piece actually contains no facts whatsoever.

I almost feel sorry for Spiers, a fast-rising blog queen who writes gossipy pieces about the New York business scene. Someone made her feel damn awful about not buying local – "I can't help but think that death and dismemberment are implied if I don't buy the sweater knit by area hipsters or locally grown produce" — and now she has decided to punish the rest of us for it. So a note to her follows.

***

Elizabeth, let me offer an apology on behalf of locavores across the country. We're truly sorry you were made to feel bad about your shopping habits. You should never have to "risk a condescending eye roll when I protest, 'It's a cheaper and identical tomato.'"

But, methinks you protest too much.

You may "see exclamation-mark-laden signs in neighborhood stores that 'I buy local,'" but these kinds of signs are actually increasingly rare. The more common phrase is "Think Local First," deployed precisely to calm folks like yourself who have limited resistance to Big Box temptations.

We don't seek perfection. We just want you to become a smarter shopper, to find cheaper produce that's also locally grown, to realize that your Starbucks latte is almost never your cheapest cup of Joe (or, in New York City, remotely your tastiest), and to make modest shifts in your purchasing behavior that can benefit your personal and your community's bottom lines.

Elizabeth, I'm disappointed you didn't talk to a single person who promotes local when writing your piece. I don't know how else to explain the absence of "Think Local First" from your discussion. Plus, you don’t seem to know what "local" means.

"The emotional tenor," you write "is much more about shunning corporate behemoths. If the farmer next door happens to be Monsanto, you rethink buying local." But local business refers to local ownership, not proximity.

And where do you get economic arguments like the following? "As for local money staying in the local economy, when you walk into your least-favorite national chain store, no one working behind the counter is likely to be [...] nonlocal. Nor are the recipients of its property taxes or many of the vendors that service it."

Elizabeth, research was apparently not your best subject at school. No problem. Let's review some studies that carry more weight than your opinion.

Sure, all stores – local and nonlocal – hire local people and pay taxes. But we know that locally owned businesses contribute significantly greater levels of income, wealth, jobs, taxes, and charity to a community. Here's a brief tutorial in how we know this, in case you're interested:

Local Economics 101

Five years ago Civic Economics, a cutting-edge economic development group, analyzed the relative impact of a proposed Borders bookstore in Austin, Texas, as compared to two local bookstores the chain was gunning to put out of business. The researchers found that one hundred dollars spent at the Borders would circulate thirteen dollars in the Austin economy, while the same one hundred dollars spent at either of the two local stores would circulate forty-five dollars.

Greater local spending means a higher "economic multiplier," the benefits that flow from a dollar circulating many times in a community. The Austin study suggested that every dollar spent at the local store contributed three times the jobs to the local economy, three times the boost to income, three times the tax benefits.

In 2004, Civic Economics improved its methodology and completed another study of Andersonville, a neighborhood in Chicago. The principal finding was that a dollar spent at a local restaurant generated 25 percent more economic multiplier than a chain. The local advantage was 63 percent higher multiplier for local retail, and 90 percent higher for local services.

A year ago, Civic Economics did its most in-depth study yet, encompassing the City of San Francisco and neighboring communities of South San Francisco, Colma, and Daly City. Looking at books, toys, sporting goods, and fast food, the researchers found that if San Franciscans shifted just 10 cents of every dollar of their spending from chain stores to local retailers, they could add to the city's economy nearly 1,300 more jobs and $200 million more in annual output. The bad news is this: If 10 percent of local purchasing drifts to the chains, the region could lose 1,300 jobs and $200 million of annual output.

Elizabeth, if you believe these studies are wrong, or wish to point to contrary evidence, we welcome your argument. But please don't just pretend these studies don't exist.

And one more bone to pick. We’re the ones who are "condescending" in this discussion? Here’s what you wrote: "What buying local really means is buying boutique-branded artisanal products that are crafted by tender loving care by actual human beings." Talk about stereotyping....

In fact, roughly half the entire economy is made up of small, local businesses. In all but seven of the 1100 categories of industry the U.S. government keeps track of there are more examples of competitive small businesses than large ones. Get real, Elizabeth.

You do make a good point at the end of your essay: "Large corporations," you write, "certainly aren’t unaware of local appeal and are happy to exploit it as a marketing tool. Every gargantuan retail-financial institution in the country declares itself your 'friendly neighborhood bank.'"

But then you imply, illogically, that such local-wash means concern about the local economy shouldn't matter. Or, worse, that the emergence of deceptive advertising is somehow the fault of local businesses and local-minded consumers? Isn't this blaming the victim? And excusing the perpetrator?

Dumping on small business is easy if you’re being well rewarded for it. Rumor has it that this column for Fast Company is your last and your new employer is Fortune. How appropriate.

By Michael H. Shuman

Re: Memo to Obama Transition Team: Home-Run Policies for ...

Submitted by Jets Shop (not verified) on September 2, 2010 - 9:24pm.

Jets Jerseys
Mark Sanchez Jersey
LaDainian Tomlinson Jersey
Antonio Cromartie Jersey
Brett Favre Jersey
Darrelle Revis Jersey
Dustin Keller Jersey
Jerricho Cotchery Jersey
Joe Namath Jersey
Jonathan Vilma Jersey
Laveranues Coles Jersey
Leon Washington Jersey
Santonio Holmes Jersey
Shonn Greene Jersey
Thomas Jones Jersey
Vernon Gholston Jersey
Jets Men's Jerseys
Jets Authentic Jerseys
Jets Premier Jerseys
Jets Replica Jerseys
Jets Women's Jerseys
Jets Kids Jerseys
Jets Hats
Cowboys shop
Cowboys Jersey
Miles Austin Jersey
Tony Romo Jerseys
Dez Bryant Jersey
Saints Jerseys
Reggie Bush Jerseys
Drew Brees Jerseys
Garrett Hartley Jerseys
Scott Fujita Jerseys

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 2, 2010 - 5:40am.

While most of the other couples are already prepping for the upcoming season of "Dancing With the Stars," there are two MBT
dancers who have yet to even meet.

Karina Smirnoff and "JerseyMBT Shoes
Shore" star Mike "The Situation" Sorrentino haven't even spoken to each other yet, but Smirnoff is sure they will have a lot to catch up on when he does eventuallyMbt Cleanrance make it to rehearsalsMBT Walking Shoes sometime later this month.

"I'm excited and nervous MBT Shoes Shop
and I have all these weird emotions, MBT Barabara but I'm mostly excited," Smirnoff told MTV News on MBT Changa Wednesday (September 1). "I MBT Chapa
think were literallyMBT Chili the only couple who will only have aboutMBT Fanaka
five days to get ready for the premiere on nationalMBT Karani television. Everyone else is going to have three and half weeks. MBT Kaya
We're gonna have maybe five days, so that part I'm very nervousMBT Lami about. I know I have to be very MBT M Walk clever in the choreography, because five days is just notMBT Sandals enough. Even if you're a professional dancer, it would be really, really tough toMBT Shuguli get ready. So we might try to implement the fist-pumping for the first episode."

Smirnoff joked that MBT Sport she thinks that the Situation's only dancing experience is in SeasideMBT Tariki Heights nightclubs, so she knows it's going to take some creative solutions on her end to MBT Tataga make him look like a professional dancer. "Once I meet him for the first time, whenever he's here, MBT Tembea that would be literally the first time I see him [and] I speak to him [and] I have any kind MBT Tunisha of contact with him, so leading up to that, I will try to create, like, variations, MBT Voi
little pieces of choreography," she explained. "It's trial and error."

And if fans think MBT Shoes Sorrentino will just be showing up shirtless week after week, Smirnoff is hoping they can show MBT Walking Shoes a new side of the TV star. "I was thinking, again, it's all about seeing where his mind is. Cheap MBT Shoes If that was up to me, we all know Mike as Mike 'The Situation' from 'Jersey Shore,' so MBT Sneakers I think it'd be nice to still have Mike as Mike that we know, but also show some more insightMBT Barabara Shoes into him wearing a tuxedo, wearing something we've never seen. MBT Changa Shoes I hope we're able to give different sides of Mike.

"He looks like he's in great physical shape, MBT Chapa Shoes and that's a plus and a minus," MBT Chili Shoes she said. "I don't know if Michael is ready, but he's going to be stretched out to hisMBT Fanaka Gtx Shoes limits, physically speaking."
MBT Karani Shoes
MBT Kaya Shoes
MBT Lami Shoes
MBT M.Walk Shoes
MBT Sandals
MBT Shuguli Gtx Shoes
MBT Sport Shoes
MBT Tariki Shoes
MBT Tataga Shoes
MBT Tembea Shoes
MBT Tunisha Shoes
MBT Voi Shoes

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 1, 2010 - 6:44am.

dell laptop batteries,laptop batteries, laptop charger, hp battery, dell inspiron 6000 battery dell inspiron 6000 hp adapter acer ac adapter vgp ac19v19 hp laptop battery hp ac adapter hp laptop batteries pa3399u 2brs skype phone dell laptop battery laptop battery gateway laptop battery sony vaio laptop battery dell ac adapter hp ac adapter toshiba laptop battery, leather handbags fashion handbags aluminum briefcase, aluminum cosmetic case aluminum tool case, aluminum train case. hp laptop battery ibm thinkpad battery acer laptop battery huolishaoseo

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by Samantha (not verified) on August 31, 2010 - 1:11pm.

Those who lack the ability to write quality essays for their term paper or college research project look towards other alternatives. There are many alternative present over the Internet who are professional and competent to provide these students with good quality essays at a budget.
academic essay writing

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by xihayizu (not verified) on August 29, 2010 - 5:45am.

This model of eye-catching dazzling ring, it decorates designs swarovski boldly, the beautiful good-looking Bordeaux red swarovski crystals quartz, it enables you to become people's attention focal point! This section classical to plate swarovski beads the golden color ring is decorated by the big cutting quartz, the development swarovski bracelet warm like fire; it makes the dark red charm which one is enchanted.

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by xihayizu (not verified) on August 29, 2010 - 5:43am.

It attracts much attention and it takes New York as a swarovski terminal, at the appointed time this series magnificent enchanting swarovski crystals high-quality fashionable clothing can penetrate the swarovski jewelry auction form to contribute completely, but this splendid charitable grand meeting by to will swarovski wholesale hold the high-level auction with to handle the vanguard to design the high-quality goods to be famous, it enjoys New York auction business Phillips who has the great reputation to manage.

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by aa (not verified) on August 28, 2010 - 8:49am.

Galipette series to get drunk with Paris evening party for the chanelyoung beautiful inspiration, show the strong contrast, exciting youth girls shy and between the metropolis replica handbagsyoung woman between women and mature lasting appeal will be fine and rich inner feelings with proper.For the past, Prada masterpiece is not only the quarterly risk, remember that It prada 1984 that only nylon bag?

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by xihayizu (not verified) on August 28, 2010 - 5:31am.

Complete abandonment old generation traditional clock and watch swarovski design style, what displaces will be fills futurism and the person or swarovski crystals household who refuses to move and bargains for swarovski jewelry unreasonably high compensation when the land is requisitioned for a construction project vigor swarovski necklace design. This act extremely take risks, but it swarovski earrings has the brand abundant resources support, this is nothing unusual.

Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes

Submitted by Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes (not verified) on August 27, 2010 - 7:46am.

We have Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes | Cheap Christian Louboutin Shoes with top quality for women show women's taste.A pair of Christian Louboutin Boots | Christian Louboutin Boots in your closet will help you to transform any outfit.Christian Louboutin thigh high boots | Christian Louboutin thigh high boots are going mainstream.Choose the height of the heels to suit your personal preference. And Christian Louboutin Tall Boots | Christian Louboutin Tall Boots are coupled with sound support to showcase their beautiful legs.Christian Louboutin not only provide a variety of pumps, sandals, but also Christian Louboutin Ankle Boots | Christian Louboutin Ankle Boots.With Christian Louboutin sandals | Christian Louboutin sandals,you'll be charming, sexy, and so sophisticated.It seems that people who always love to choose Christian Louboutin short boots | Christian Louboutin short boots.Never be surprised if someone tells you she got a pair of Christian Louboutin Pumps | Christian Louboutin Pumps proudly.However many forget that they have some interesting Christian louboutin men's shoes | Christian louboutin men's shoes designs up their sleeves.

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by jewellery (not verified) on August 25, 2010 - 8:27am.

However, if your jewels links of london don’t match with your face shape and hair style, they will not play the role as ornaments. Therefore, the importance of the match between jewels and hair style and face shape can’t be stressed too much. Hope the links of london jewellery following information may help you. Here are some tips for you to choose and match jewelries. Hope to have some assistance. The jewels you chose should be matched with your clothes, age, complexion, etc. so as to stand out you. The most important code: on one hand, your jewels can’t be the same links of london charms shape with your face; on the other hand, they can’t be extremely different from your face shape. The best jewel piece for a girl with a heart-shape face is the one that is wider at the bottom because once again that links of london sale will balance out that chin.

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by jewellery (not verified) on August 25, 2010 - 8:24am.

It is by no means unusual to links of london see women shuttling among jewelry stores where various jewelries have great attraction to them. Â People born links under Libra are often fair and elegant. Â Since jewels, as an indispensable ornament to dresses, play an important role in displaying one's distinctive personalities if they are properly matched. Maybe you are obsessed with various links of london jewellery jewelries, but have you ever considered that whether the jewelries you obtained are really suitable for you? Do they links of london bracelet highlight you?

Classic Cardy Ugg Boots

Submitted by Classic Cardy Ugg Boots (not verified) on August 25, 2010 - 3:52am.

So many people love Classic Cardy Ugg Boots | Classic Cardy Ugg Boots now.If you want to sent your friend a birthday present,I advice you give him or her a pair of Ultra Short UGG Boots | Ultra Short UGG Boots os his/her birthday gift!For modern women, who love beauty most, Classic Mini UGG Boots | Classic Mini UGG Boots show them an irresistible charming,The feature of Classic Metallic UGG Boots | Classic Metallic UGG Boots is that it can keep your feet dry and suit for you to wear in all seasons.What's more the Highkoo UGG Boots | Highkoo UGG Boots is a fun, modern update to one of our heritage styles, Fluff Flip Flop UGG Slippers | Fluff Flip Flop UGG Slippers is one of new 2010 fall series. Classic UGG Boots | Classic UGG Boots are perfect for you when you are around home or even when you are going out.

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by jewellery (not verified) on August 23, 2010 - 8:18am.

Have you ever been longing for links of london earrings? Of course, the love for beauty is a nature of all human beings, especially girls. How many times have we links of london jewellery wandered in front of special counter and shrunk back at the sight of its prohibitive price! Now let’s enjoy luxurious friendship bracelets at affordable price here.
Famous and favorite designs, for people who appreciate the best. London silvers offers all kinds of exqusite Links London Bracelets for your personal taste. We promise you can buy them at lowest price online.

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on August 21, 2010 - 11:47pm.

Abercrombie & Fitch store: discount Abercrombie Fitch clothing, cheap A & F clothes, outwears, sweaters, and other accessories for men and women are at
abercrombie
Abercrombie Fitch
Abercrombie Fitch Clothes
abercrombie Mens Hoodies
abercrombie Womens Hoodies
louis vuitton
louis vuitton salesomehow the fault of local businesses and local-minded consumers? Isn't this blaming the victim? And excusing the perpetrator?
Abercrombie Womens Pants
Abercrombie Womens Premium Sweaters
Abercrombie and Fitch

Re: Not-So-Fast Company: Elizabeth Spiers

Submitted by dress (not verified) on August 19, 2010 - 3:32am.

Shop prom dresses, formal dresses, prom shoes, 2010 designer prom gowns at PromGirl. Find homecoming,
cocktail dresses, graduation dresses,plus-size formal
evening dresses
Prom dresses
wedding dresses
on best wedding dresses for 2009 and 2010. You can find latest collection of woman's dresses and casual dresses on this site
discount Prom dresses
discount wedding dresses
autoradio navigation, car dvd gps navigation, sat navigation stereo, OEM Factory headunit for all car makes
Higher quality car electronics from Qualir
Car DVD Player
Car GPS